Skip to content
Techlitic
  • Type at least two characters.

Laptop comparison

Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon vs HP 17

Lenovo · 2017

Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon
  • Intel Core i5-8250U
  • 256 GB
  • 14″
5.5

HP · 2016+

HP 17
  • AMD 9420
  • 1 TB - 2 TB
  • 17.3″
3.4

Our verdict

The Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon is lighter and supports Windows 11

It has a faster processor (Core i7-8565U vs Core i5-8250U), a lighter body (1.13 kg vs 2.6 kg) and more CPU cores (4 / 8 vs 2 / 2). The HP 17 has more storage (1 TB - 2 TB vs 256 GB) and a faster boost clock (3.6 GHz vs 3.4 GHz). On our laptop scale the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon scores 5.5 out of 10 and the HP 17 3.4.

Scores side by side

Techlitic estimates out of 10. How we score

Lenovo ThinkPad X1 CarbonHP 17
  • 2.5
    Processor
    1.6
  • 1.0
    Graphics
    0.9
  • 4.0
    Memory & storage
    9.3
  • 7.9
    Display
    3.1
  • 6.1
    Battery
    4.3
  • 9.7
    Portability
    2.8
  • 5.5
    Connectivity
    –
  • 8.0
    Software support
    1.5

Where each one wins

Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon

  • A faster processorCore i7-8565U vs Core i5-8250U
  • A lighter body1.13 kg vs 2.6 kg
  • More CPU cores4 / 8 vs 2 / 2
  • A bigger battery57 Wh vs 41 Wh
  • A sharper screen157 ppi - 210 ppi vs 106 ppi

HP 17

  • More storage1 TB - 2 TB vs 256 GB
  • A faster boost clock3.6 GHz vs 3.4 GHz

Full comparison

Specs side by side

16 measurable differences

Lenovo ThinkPad X1 CarbonSpecHP 17
Performance
Intel Core i5-8250U(better)ProcessorAMD 9420
2.2-2.8 / 10, by configuration(better)Processor score0.9-2.2 / 10, by configuration
Intel Core i7-8565UOther processor optionsAMD 9620P, Intel Core i5-8250U
8th gen, Kaby Lake R, 2017(better)Processor generation8th gen, 2016
4 / 8(better)Cores / threads2 / 2
3.4 GHzMax clock speed3.6 GHz(better)
3 MB(better)L3 cache1 MB
Intel UHD Graphics 620(better)GraphicsAMD Radeon R5
1.0 / 10(better)Graphics score0.7-1.0 / 10, by configuration
Gen 9.5, 2017(better)Graphics generationGCN, 2015
IntegratedGraphics typeIntegrated
Memory & storage
LPDDR3Memory typeDDR4
2,133 MHz(better)Memory speed1,866 MHz
Yes, not upgradableRAM soldered-
256 GBStorage1 TB - 2 TB(better)
1 × M.2SSD slots-
Display
14″Screen size17.3″
1920 × 1080, 2560 × 1440(better)Resolution1600 × 900, 1920 × 1080
157 ppi - 210 ppi(better)Pixel density106 ppi
IPSPanel typeIPS
OptionalTouchscreenNo
Battery & power
57 Wh(better)Battery capacity41 Wh
-Claimed battery life8.5 hours
65 WCharger45 W
Design
1.13 kg(better)Weight2.6 kg
15.9 mm(better)Thickness24.6 mm
324 × 217 mmDimensions (W × D)415 × 278 mm
January 2017Released2016 or later
Windows 10 ProOperating systemWindows 10 Home
ThinkPadFamily-
ThinkPad XSeries-
20HR0062MDExample part number1UR34EA
Ports & connectivity
Wi-Fi 5Wi-Fi-
4.1Bluetooth4.2
NoThunderbolt-
2USB-C-
MicroSD (TransFlash)Card readerSD
Webcam, audio & security
YesWebcamYes
-Optical driveDVD Super Multi

Highlighted values are better on paper. A dash means we don't have that spec yet. Processor and graphics scores are Techlitic estimates against laptops on sale in 2026.

More Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon comparisons

Lenovo ThinkPad X1 CarbonVSLenovo ThinkPad T470sLenovo ThinkPad X1 CarbonVSLenovo ThinkPad X280Lenovo ThinkPad X1 CarbonVSLenovo ThinkPad T490sLenovo ThinkPad X1 CarbonVSHP EliteBook 840 G5Lenovo ThinkPad Yoga 370VSLenovo ThinkPad X1 CarbonLenovo ThinkPad X1 CarbonVSLenovo ThinkPad T470

More HP 17 comparisons

HP 15VSHP 17HP 17VSAcer Aspire 5 A517-51Lenovo IdeaPad 330VSHP 17Lenovo IdeaPad L340VSHP 17Lenovo Yoga 710VSHP 17HP Pavilion 17VSHP 17