Laptop comparison
Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon vs HP 17
Our verdict
The Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon is lighter and supports Windows 11
It has a faster processor (Core i7-8565U vs Core i5-8250U), a lighter body (1.13 kg vs 2.6 kg) and more CPU cores (4 / 8 vs 2 / 2). The HP 17 has more storage (1 TB - 2 TB vs 256 GB) and a faster boost clock (3.6 GHz vs 3.4 GHz). On our laptop scale the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon scores 5.5 out of 10 and the HP 17 3.4.
Scores side by side
Techlitic estimates out of 10. How we score
Lenovo ThinkPad X1 CarbonHP 17
- Processor2.51.6
- Graphics1.00.9
- Memory & storage4.09.3
- Display7.93.1
- Battery6.14.3
- Portability9.72.8
- Connectivity5.5–
- Software support8.01.5
Where each one wins
Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon
- A faster processorCore i7-8565U vs Core i5-8250U
- A lighter body1.13 kg vs 2.6 kg
- More CPU cores4 / 8 vs 2 / 2
- A bigger battery57 Wh vs 41 Wh
- A sharper screen157 ppi - 210 ppi vs 106 ppi
HP 17
- More storage1 TB - 2 TB vs 256 GB
- A faster boost clock3.6 GHz vs 3.4 GHz
Full comparison
Specs side by side
16 measurable differences
| Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon | Spec | HP 17 |
|---|---|---|
| Performance | ||
| Intel Core i5-8250U(better) | Processor | AMD 9420 |
| 2.2-2.8 / 10, by configuration(better) | Processor score | 0.9-2.2 / 10, by configuration |
| Intel Core i7-8565U | Other processor options | AMD 9620P, Intel Core i5-8250U |
| 8th gen, Kaby Lake R, 2017(better) | Processor generation | 8th gen, 2016 |
| 4 / 8(better) | Cores / threads | 2 / 2 |
| 3.4 GHz | Max clock speed | 3.6 GHz(better) |
| 3 MB(better) | L3 cache | 1 MB |
| Intel UHD Graphics 620(better) | Graphics | AMD Radeon R5 |
| 1.0 / 10(better) | Graphics score | 0.7-1.0 / 10, by configuration |
| Gen 9.5, 2017(better) | Graphics generation | GCN, 2015 |
| Integrated | Graphics type | Integrated |
| Memory & storage | ||
| LPDDR3 | Memory type | DDR4 |
| 2,133 MHz(better) | Memory speed | 1,866 MHz |
| Yes, not upgradable | RAM soldered | - |
| 256 GB | Storage | 1 TB - 2 TB(better) |
| 1 × M.2 | SSD slots | - |
| Display | ||
| 14″ | Screen size | 17.3″ |
| 1920 × 1080, 2560 × 1440(better) | Resolution | 1600 × 900, 1920 × 1080 |
| 157 ppi - 210 ppi(better) | Pixel density | 106 ppi |
| IPS | Panel type | IPS |
| Optional | Touchscreen | No |
| Battery & power | ||
| 57 Wh(better) | Battery capacity | 41 Wh |
| - | Claimed battery life | 8.5 hours |
| 65 W | Charger | 45 W |
| Design | ||
| 1.13 kg(better) | Weight | 2.6 kg |
| 15.9 mm(better) | Thickness | 24.6 mm |
| 324 × 217 mm | Dimensions (W × D) | 415 × 278 mm |
| January 2017 | Released | 2016 or later |
| Windows 10 Pro | Operating system | Windows 10 Home |
| ThinkPad | Family | - |
| ThinkPad X | Series | - |
| 20HR0062MD | Example part number | 1UR34EA |
| Ports & connectivity | ||
| Wi-Fi 5 | Wi-Fi | - |
| 4.1 | Bluetooth | 4.2 |
| No | Thunderbolt | - |
| 2 | USB-C | - |
| MicroSD (TransFlash) | Card reader | SD |
| Webcam, audio & security | ||
| Yes | Webcam | Yes |
| - | Optical drive | DVD Super Multi |
Highlighted values are better on paper. A dash means we don't have that spec yet. Processor and graphics scores are Techlitic estimates against laptops on sale in 2026.